What's the problem?
If someone else holds your shares on your behalf, on the understanding that they'll transfer them back to you when the time is right, you're relying entirely on them keeping their word. There's often nothing formal stopping them from simply refusing when that time comes. This is more common than people think, particularly in the early stages of a business, and it usually works fine, right up until it doesn't.
Here's how it played out for one client of ours, an experienced healthcare professional. She'd previously worked in business with another person, someone with a good commercial head but no healthcare background and no formal accountancy training. Those earlier ventures had ended, and she'd moved on.
A new opportunity came up: a healthcare company, in receipt of public funding, in a similar space. Her old contact was involved again. At the outset, it wasn't attractive for her to be listed as a director, so they agreed a different structure. He'd hold the sole directorship, and he'd be the one recorded as holding 100% of the shares, both on the company's own register and in its filings at Companies House.
He held the legal title, and on paper he was the shareholder. But her case was that he was only ever holding those shares for her, and that she was the one who was actually entitled to them.
What changed?
Some time later, her circumstances improved and it was time to correct the position so it properly reflected what had been agreed. She asked him to transfer the shares back.
He didn't refuse outright. Instead, he raised something new: keeping some shares for himself, as remuneration for having acted as director. In principle, she agreed to 10%. He later pushed for 20%. She never confirmed or denied that, and in the absence of an actual agreement, nothing was settled.
Then nothing happened. No transfer. No correction to the company's records. Time passed, and the two of them reached deadlock.
On top of that, despite working in the business day-to-day as CEO, she had no access to the management accounts. All she knew was that the bills were being paid each month. Beyond that, no visibility into the company's financial position at all. That's when she came to us.
What does the law say?
An arrangement like this, where one person holds shares on behalf of another, doesn't need to be in writing to be real and enforceable. But if it's disputed, whoever is claiming the benefit of it has to be able to prove it, from what was actually said, done, and understood between the two of them at the time. That's exactly what we did here, working through the history and the documents our client had access to.
Who's listed as the shareholder on paper isn't necessarily the same as who's actually entitled to the value of the shares. Those are two separate questions, and the second one is decided on the evidence, not just on who's listed where.
Where someone won't put the record straight voluntarily, there's a route to ask the court to correct it. That's a real option, but it isn't automatic. You still have to be able to show the underlying entitlement clearly, and the court has a genuine discretion over whether to make the correction.
Where a director is also being blocked from seeing the company's accounts, the law is clear that directors are entitled to inspect the company's accounting records at any time. That's a separate point from the shareholding dispute, but it often comes up alongside it, as it did here.
What did we actually do about it?
First, we worked out how strong the underlying claim really was, before deciding what to give up.
The evidence supported her claim to at least 80% of the shares, and we were fortunate that he had confirmed it in writing. The remaining 20% he was pushing for was arguable, but not worth fighting over. So she didn't. That single decision took away the one issue the other side could have dragged out for months, and let us build the whole case around the 80% that wasn't in doubt.
Then we lined up two objectives, in a strict order.
Get the company's records corrected to reflect her true shareholding.
Use the voting power that came with it to get her appointed director, and him removed.
Removal as director was the actual route to financial transparency. But you don't get the votes without being properly recognised as the shareholder first. So that had to happen first.
We sent a detailed letter before claim, setting out the legal position and the remedies available, including that we were prepared to go to court to get the position corrected if he didn't cooperate.
When he tried to bundle the share issue together with an exit negotiation, we said no. Repeatedly.
His response to the letter was to insist that any resolution include a sale of his shares, an exit deal, in other words. There was no obligation on our client to agree to that as the price of getting her own shareholding recognised, so we declined.
He tried two lines of pressure, and neither landed:
"There should be a reasonable, global resolution."
Correcting the record was a matter of entitlement, not something to be traded against an unrelated exit proposal.
"There will be cost consequences in court if you don't engage on exit."
We didn't accept that there was any obligation to negotiate a buyout simply to get her own position recognised, and on these facts, that held up.
Keeping those two issues separate, correcting the record now, any exit conversation later if ever, is what stopped him using one as leverage over the other.
Once the principle was agreed, we followed the correct legal process carefully at every stage. The exact steps depend on the company's own constitution and the shares involved, and any misstep can hand the other side a technical objection to hide behind. We made sure every notice, meeting and resolution was properly done.
Why the order mattered
Correcting the record first. He only agreed to put things right once it was clear we were prepared to ask the court to do it for him. Without a firm grip on the legal position, he probably wouldn't have moved at all.
Directorship second. With her shareholding properly recognised, we secured her appointment as director, following the correct process for the company.
Removal third. The bank accounts were still blocked. Only once her shareholding gave her real voting control could she use the proper procedure to call a meeting and remove him as director. He kept his 20%, but lost all control.
What typically goes wrong without advice?
Assuming the other side will do the right thing eventually. An informal understanding like this is only worth as much as the other side's willingness to honour it once things change, and proving it later depends on the evidence you actually have.
Letting two issues get bundled together. An exit negotiation, a cost threat, an appeal to "reasonableness", all designed to make a straightforward entitlement feel negotiable. It usually isn't, but it's worth taking advice before you decide that for yourself.
Getting the process wrong. Correcting a shareholding, or removing a director, has to be done properly. Miss a step and you hand the other side a technical challenge that undoes months of work.
Staying in the dark on the numbers for too long. If you're a director and you're being denied access to the accounts, that's worth acting on quickly rather than waiting it out.
What was the outcome?
The company's records were corrected to reflect her true 80% shareholding. She was appointed director. Then, once she had real voting control, she was able to remove the other director entirely. He kept his 20% shareholding, but lost all control of the company.
Once she finally had access to the bank accounts, it became clear there'd been significant financial mismanagement during the period she'd been shut out. That's a separate matter, being dealt with now, but it could only come to light once the shareholding and directorship questions were resolved.
Can Pinpoint Lawyers help if I'm in this position?
We specialise in shareholder and director disputes, including cases involving beneficial ownership arrangements that aren't being honoured. If someone is holding your shares and refusing to hand them back, or you've been shut out of financial oversight in your own company, get in touch and we'll advise you on the best route for your specific circumstances.

